Systematic review of the Hawthorne effect: New concepts are needed to study research participation effects

Keywords

Hawthorne effect, Observational study, Artifact (error), Empirical research, Research design

References

• Impact of the Hawthorne effect in a longitudinal clinical study: the case of anesthesia.D. De Amici, Catherine Klersy, Felice Ramajoli — 2000
• The Impact of the Hawthorne Effect in Experimental Designs in Educational Research. Final Report.Desmond L. Cook — 1967
• The "Hawthorne effect"--what did the original Hawthorne studies actually show?Gustav Wickström, Theo. Bendix — 2000
• The Management and the WorkerGeorge Francis Johnson — 2008
• The Human Problems of an Industrial CivilizationMayo, Elton — 1934
• Manufacturing Knowledge: A History of the Hawthorne ExperimentsRonald Schultz — 1993
• The Hawthorne experiments: First statistical interpretation.Richard H. Franke, James D. Kaul — 1978
• The Hawthorne dogma.Robert Sommer — 1968
• Effect of blinding and unmasking on the quality of peer review: a randomized trial.Susan van Rooyen, Fiona Godlee, Stephen Evans — 1998
• The Hawthorne effect in the measurement of adolescent smoking.Michael Murray, A V Swan, S. Kiryluk — 1988
• Nonspecific effects in longitudinal studies: impact on quality of life measures.Christine Bouchet, F. Guillemin, S. Briançon — 1996
• Research Methods in the Behavioral Sciences.Donald F. Blankertz, Léon Festinger, Daniel Katz — 1954
• Hawthorne Control Procedures in Educational Experiments: A Reconsideration of Their Use and EffectivenessJohn G. Adair, Donald Sharpe, Cam‐Loi Huynh — 1989
• Hawthorne effects and research into professional practice.John D. Holden — 2001
• What Happened at Hawthorne?H. McIlvaine Parsons — 1974
• Recontextualizing the Hawthorne effectMagnus Hansson, Rune Wigblad — 2006
• Compliance of health care workers to hand hygiene: awareness of being observed is importantÉric Maury, Nael Moussa, Choukri Lakermi — 2006
• Is patient satisfaction sensitive to changes in the quality of care? An exploitation of the Hawthorne effect.Kenneth L. Leonard — 2008
• The Hawthorne studies-a fable for our times?Elaine Gale — 2004
• An Assessment of the Hawthorne Effect in Practice-based ResearchDouglas H. Fernald, Laura P. Coombs, Lauren DeAlleaume — 2012

Cited by

• Positional skull deformation in infants: heading towards evidence-based practiceRenske M. van Wijk — 2014
• Hawthorne Effect with Transient Behavioral and Biochemical Changes in a Randomized Controlled Sleep Extension Trial of Chronically Short-Sleeping Obese Adults: Implications for the Design and Interpretation of Clinical StudiesT. P. Bhowmik, Soham Ray, Arun Kumar Singh — 2014
• Effects of study design and allocation on self-reported alcohol consumption: randomized trialHovonogila — 2015
• Acute low back pain management in primary care: a simulated patient approach.Canh‐Dung Tran — 2015
• Radiologist Productivity Increases With Real-Time Monitoring: The Hawthorne Effect.Keijiro Yamazaki — 2015
• The Hawthorne Effect in Infection Prevention and EpidemiologySerge Fanello — 2015
• Social self-value intervention for empowerment of HIV infected people using antiretroviral treatment: a randomized controlled trialKathryn Berry Bertram — 2016
• Incidence of Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome--Reply.Will J. Jordan, Robert G. Cooper — 2016
• Extended-Release Guaifenesin/Pseudoephedrine Hydrochloride for Symptom Relief in Support of a Wait-and-See Approach for the Treatment of Acute Upper Respiratory Tract Infections: A Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled StudyDaniel Alberto Sabsay — 2017
• Access to Medical Records’ Impact on Community Pharmacist–Delivered Medication Therapy Management: A Pilot From the Medication Safety Research Network of Indiana (Rx-SafeNet)隆広 新井, 俊明 小暮, 英里子 蛭田 — 2018
• Development and Validation of a Multi-Algorithm Analytic Platform to Detect Off-Target Mechanical VentilationAli Rosidi — 2017
• Personalized video feedback improves suturing skills of incoming general surgery traineesNimesh D. Naik, Eduardo Abbott, Becca L. Gas — 2018
• Temporal increases in 25-hydroxyvitamin D in midlife women: Longitudinal results from the Study of Women’s Health Across the Nation (SWAN)Luis Fernando Álvarez González — 2019
• En sjuksköterskas följsamhet till basala hygienrutiner : En studie utifrån Theory of Planned BehaviourFrida Söderström — 2014
• Mouse Models for Drug DiscoveryGabriele Proetzel, Michael V. Wiles — 2016
• Development of conceptual framework and methodology for enhancing long term coping skills to improve psychological and physiological well-beingS. Dean — 2014
• Likely effect of adding flexible sigmoidoscopy to the English NHS Bowel Cancer Screening Programme: impact on colorectal cancer cases and deathsSandra M. E. Geurts, Nathalie J. Massat, Stephen W. Duffy — 2015
• No time to think: policy, pedagogy and professional learningSimon N. Leonard, Philip Roberts — 2016
• Virtues, ecological momentary assessment/intervention and smartphone technologyJason D. Runyan, Ellen Steinke — 2015
• Assessment Effects in Educational and Psychosocial Intervention Trials: An Important but Often-Overlooked ProblemMi‐Kyung Song, Sandra E. Ward — 2015

Related papers

• A framework for applying unfamiliar trial designs in studies of rare diseases.Samir Gupta, Marie E. Faughnan, George Tomlinson — 2011
• Statistical Issues in Research I: Overview of Epidemiological Study DesignAdesola Z. Musa, Paschal Mbanefo Ezeobi — 2015
• Behavioral Headache Research: Methodologic Considerations and Research Design AlternativesKarl G. Hursey, Jeanetta Rains, Donald Penzien — 2005
• Observational and interventional study design types; an overviewMatthew S. Thiese — 2014
• Methodology Rigor in Clinical ResearchLynda J.‐S. Yang, Kate Chang, Kevin C. Chung — 2012
• Overview of Clinical Research Study Designs Using Examples From the Swallowing LiteratureAngela M. Malek, John S. Luque, Kendrea L. Garand — 2017